Why so many options?
Tonight I'm trying a 5 Vegas Apotheosis (5.5IN x 55) Which translates to a 5-1/2IN long cigar with a 55 ring diameter. Now may I cut this cigar with 64 ring cutter. Yes you may. Can I cut this cigar with a v-cutter. Yes you can. What about a punch cutter. Acceptable as well. Each cutter can effect draw. Different cutters on different cigars can substantially affect the draw. I prefer to use my 56 ring guillotine cutter on cigars with a smaller ring size for a more precise cut without concern of cleanliness of the cut. This is all personal preference.
I personally prefer a guillotine cutter, gives a much more consistent draw. A punch cutter is great for keeping in your pocket and handy to use on the go. I have seen several people using a v-cutter to cut multiple v grooves in their cigars. Some like an X others like an asterisk. Simply in order to help with draw on very tightly wrapped cigars.
Regardless how you cut this 5 Vegas Apotheosis it is certain to be a new favorite. The draw was easy. The burn was consistent. The flavor was rich and the smoke was smooth.